Z.2 Select reasons to support an opinion
What is an opinion and a reason?
An opinion is what you think or feel about a topic. A reason is a statement that explains why you have that opinion, making it stronger and more convincing.
- Opinion: Our school should have more recess time.
- Reason: More recess helps students focus better in class.
A strong opinion is not just "I like it." It is a statement you can support with good reasons.
How to identify strong reasons
A strong reason is relevant, clear, and provides logical support for your opinion. It should answer the question "Why do you think that?"
- Check if it is directly connected to the opinion.
- Ask if it is a fact or a believable explanation.
- Decide if it would make someone else understand your point of view.
A reason like "because it's good" is weak. A reason like "because it improves health and teamwork" is strong and specific.
Types of supporting reasons
Good reasons can be based on facts, personal experiences, or widely accepted benefits. Using different types makes your opinion more balanced.
- Health/Safety: "Reading every day makes your brain stronger."
- Practical Benefits: "Learning to type helps you finish homework faster."
- Feelings & Community: "A class pet teaches responsibility and makes the classroom happier."
The best opinions are often supported by a mix of reasons. Think about what matters to your audience.
Selecting the best reasons
When you have several reasons, you must select the strongest ones. Choose reasons that are most relevant and have the clearest connection to your opinion.
Opinion: Third graders should learn to cook simple meals.
Possible Reasons:
1. It is fun to eat.
2. It teaches important math through measuring.
3. Chefs wear white hats.
4. It helps students learn about nutrition and be more independent.
Strong Selections: Reasons 2 and 4 are strongest because they show clear, practical benefits.
If a reason seems off-topic or is just a simple fact, it probably will not support your opinion well. Always ask, "Does this explain *why* I believe my opinion?"
Organizing reasons to support an opinion
Once you select your strongest reasons, put them in a logical order. This helps your reader follow your argument from start to finish.
- State Your Opinion: We should have a "No-Screen" hour after school.
- First Reason (Most Important): It encourages kids to play outside, which is healthy.
- Second Reason (Another Benefit): It gives families time to talk and do activities together.
- Third Reason (Wrap-up): It helps everyone get better sleep at night.
Save your most powerful reason for first or last. The first reason grabs attention, and the last reason is what your reader will remember.